But what will actually happen to the Smith Farm land has yet to be sorted out.
By Noah Bookstein
Original Air Date: Nov. 17, 2026
Host: The public came out in full force, covering a broad political spectrum, urging their local elected officials to keep standing up against state imposition. But will it move the needle? In a 3-2 vote today, the Sarasota County Commission decided to not appeal a judge’s ruling in favor of a workforce housing development going up next to the Celery Fields natural preserve. But what happens with that land is still up in the air. Noah Bookstein reports.
Noah Bookstein: Speakers packed the county commission chambers and encouraged commissioners to appeal an early November decision from Circuit Judge Hunter Carroll that ordered Sarasota County to process D.R. Horton’s application to build up to 864 apartments on the Smith Farm under Florida’s Live Local Act.
Smith Farm is a roughly 50-acre parcel neighboring Sarasota’s Celery Fields, a regional stormwater facility and favorite nature enclave of the Sarasota birding community. Dave Gravalisi, representing Sarasota Audubon Society, urged commissioners to appeal.
Dave Gravalisi: Any development other than that allowed under existing zoning is incompatible with existing land uses surrounding the Smith Farm.
NB: Helen King, also representing the Audubon Society, told commissioners the cost of appealing the decision is less than what it would cost to accommodate the new development.
Helen King: The cost for the county to do this pales in comparison to the infrastructure cost of roads, utilities and services that will occur.
NB: Lourdes Ramirez, representing the Sarasota County Council of Neighborhood Associations, encouraged the board to keep fighting in court.
Lourdes Ramirez: I understand that appealing a court decision comes with risks, but sometimes the greater risk is doing nothing. We have fought too hard to protect our communities to give up after one court decision. Please appeal this ruling. Let the higher courts decide. We have nothing to lose by continuing to fight.

Kelly Franklin
NB: Kelly Franklin told commissioners that thousands of people signed a petition urging the county to appeal the decision.
Kelly Franklin: In five days, 2,493 people signed it. They all want you to fight for our home. An appeal would strengthen your hand in negotiations, but buying one farm won’t stop the next developer. At least 18 projects totaling over 7,600 units are proposed in rural Sarasota. If you let this ruling stand, you open the floodgates.
NB: Kelly Kirschner, a former mayor of Sarasota who just ran for congress in District 16, reminded commissioners that the area helps control flooding.

Kelly Kirschner
Kelly Kirschner: We appreciate that this whole region is a stormwater bank and a mitigation bank that is protecting 36,000 homes downstream. To come in here and say “We can get 864 apartments, but give us 126 houses instead on land that is zoned for five homes” is really silly.
NB: The Live Local Act is a 2023 state law that lets developers skip local rezoning and density limits to build apartments on land not zoned for them as long as a share of the units are affordable. Hillsborough County is challenging the constitutionality of the law in court. Kirschner encouraged Sarasota to go farther than an appeal.
KK: What I would encourage you is to get beyond the appeal, to actually get aggressive, to talk to Hillsborough County that’s suing the state of Florida and start doing the things that the vast majority of citizens want you to do to address the stupidity of the Live Local Act.

Martin Hyde
NB: Martin Hyde, a frequent flyer at public meetings and recent independent state senate candidate, said this is one of the most important decisions facing commissioners.
Martin Hyde: No impact fees, no traffic studies, double density. Why on God’s earth would you consider giving up? It’s a constitutional issue as to whether municipalities have rights. That should and can only be decided by the highest courts in our state. Any commissioner who votes to give up will be betraying Sarasota and its future generations.

Quartermaine and Mast
NB: Commissioner Teresa Mast asked county stormwater director Ben Quartermaine what he thinks about adding Smith Farm to Celery Fields.
Ben Quartermaine: The Smith Farm would add significant value to the Celery Fields. It would add significant floodplain compensation and water quality improvements as well. The value of the Smith Farm is not just the property value. It’s the value of the existing floodplain compensation that that system provides.
NB: Mast, intent on the county buying Smith Farm but unsure who currently owns the land, asked D.R. Horton’s attorney Charlie Bailey whether the company would consider selling to the county. Bailey said the county never asked.
Charlie Bailey: No one from the county has reached out to D.R. Horton or myself to even inquire about purchasing the property.
NB: County Attorney Joshua Moye then read from an October email he had sent Bailey, saying the board had authorized the county to negotiate a purchase
Joshua Moye: I hate to do this. I really do. But I emailed Charlie, said, “Good afternoon, Charlie. The board voted down your settlement offer to move forward with the original 126-unit single family subdivision. They did, however, authorize us to try and negotiate a voluntary purchase price.”
NB: He also read Bailey’s reply. Bailey said he did not remember the exchange, pointing to other high profile projects he has been handling.
CB: Honestly, I have no recollection of that, between Hi Hat and Palmer Ranch and other things going on. But that’s a conversation we’d be, certainly, willing to have if the county wants to have it.
NB: Bailey said he has not discussed selling to the county with D.R. Horton and that they do not normally resell land before developing it.
The decision before the board: appeal Judge Carroll’s ruling by the December 4 deadline or accept the ruling and its implications for the county’s other Live Local lawsuits. Moye also read from a brief Attorney General James Uthmeier pertaining to one of those cases, urging the court to enforce the law as written. Mast said neither option was what she wanted for the land.
Teresa Mast: It’s a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity for us to be able to expand that regional stormwater, and I think it’s critical to our community.

Mark Smith
NB: Commissioner Mark Smith supported an appeal. He also opposed the smaller 126-home subdivision D.R. Horton is offering instead, saying construction there would push floodwater onto neighbors no matter how many homes are built.
Mark Smith: The same amount of dirt’s going to be brought in, and it’s gonna displace that much water, and it is going to flood the neighborhoods.
NB: Commissioner Tom Knight said he agreed with Smith but wanted to weigh the cost of losing. He said legal fees could mount and pointed to the attorney general’s involvement.

Tom Knight
Tom Knight: It’s very unusual to get a letter from the attorney general in situations like this. I’d never seen that before. Reading into it, that’s a clue.
NB: Knight said he was proud of Sarasota’s challenge to Live Local, said the commission did what they could and told residents to take their frustration to state lawmakers.
TK: The energy that they have should be with our local legislative delegation in Tallahassee. It is the epitome of removing home rule. And Tallahassee is now doing land use. We said no to 126 homes. We did our job. We got preempted.
NB: Knight argued that appealing and losing would end any chance of buying the land and reluctantly made the motion to accept the ruling.
TK: I don’t like the motion. I don’t like making it.
NB: The motion passed 3 to 2, with Smith and Mast opposed. New Commissioner Jim DeNiro voted with the majority without commenting during the discussion.
The board then voted unanimously to have the county attorney negotiate with D.R. Horton, using the 126-home offer as a starting point, but with the goal of the county buying the property instead. Mast asked staff to move quickly.
TM: It would be really nice if it would be expedited. And I mean expedited, like somebody’s backside’s on fire.
NB: Reporting for WSLR News, Noah Bookstein.
WSLR News aims to keep the local community informed with our 1/2 hour local news show, quarterly newspaper and social media feeds. The local news broadcast airs on Tuesdays and Thursdays at 6pm.