Some apartments would be attainable, but there is no space for the small businesses now on the site.
By Ed James III
Original Air Date: March 18, 2026
The Historic Downtown Village consists of 22 lots with 1920s cottages. Business tenants include a restaurant, cafe, offices, and retailers. Photos: Werner
Host: If you’ve driven into downtown Sarasota lately, you’ve likely noticed the Historic Downtown Village near the corner of Fruitville and 301. It’s a landmark of sorts—a cluster of colorful 1920s cottages and small businesses that feel like a holdout from an older version of this city. But a developer now wants to tear down the cottages and fill the entire block on the north side of Fruitville Road with a complex and apartments, some of which are promised to be attainable for working Sarasotans, but there are no plans for retail space in this complex. On Wednesday morning, city planners met with developers to discuss the project that would replace those cottages with a five-story residential block. WSLR’s Ed James III is following the story.
Ed James III: For many Sarasota residents, the area of Fruitville Road near US 301 is more than just a transit point—it’s the front door to our downtown. And right now, that front door is slated for a massive makeover. This morning, the City’s Development Review Committee—made up by the city planners—huddled with engineers from consulting firm Kimley-Horn to go over the fine print of a project known as 1899 Fruitville.
To understand why this is so controversial, you have to look at what’s currently there. The Historic Downtown Village is a collection of 1920s-era cottages. They aren’t just buildings; they are an incubator for Sarasota’s “quirky” retail scene—places like The Breakfast House, Siegfried’s Restaurant, local boutiques and artisan galleries.
1899 Fruitville’s south façade. The apartment complex would cover the entire block. No retail space is included in the plans.
Those buildings were saved and renovated in the late 80’s by Marlene and Alex Lancaster, who saw potential in these working-class homes when most people were looking the other way. If 1899 Fruitville gets the green light, it means the village will be erased. I reached out to the Lancasters to talk about that legacy but did not get my calls returned by deadline. Looking at the demolition plans today, that era of the village feels like it’s being erased.
The Breakfast House is one of the businesses forced to look for a new location.
The proposal on the table is what’s known as a superblock. Instead of individual cottages on 22 small lots, the developer wants to clear-cut two entire city blocks—stretching from Fruitville to 4th Street and Gillespie Avenue—to build one massive five-story residential complex with an internal parking garage.
And when I say “clear-cut,” I mean that literally.
Neighborhood organizer Kelly Franklin is trying to save the grand trees on the land.
The biggest point of friction in this morning’s meeting was the city’s Grand Tree Ordinance. Local activist Kelly Franklin has been sounding the alarm, accusing the developer of obfuscating the fact that they plan to remove five healthy, protected Grand Oaks. These are massive trees that provide the very canopy that makes that corner bearable in the Florida heat. Kelly Franklin has been very clear on this: she says developers have no entitlement to remove these trees and that the city must stand up for the rule of law to protect the shared environment.
So, why is the city even considering this? Well, the proposal is largely within local zoning parameters for this land. The developer is using city and state density bonuses to add more height and more units, promising that 15% of the 324 apartments will be attainable for people making 80 to 120% of the area’s median income. That is a carrot for those concerned about the lack of affordable housing.
Location of the project: On the north side of Fruitville Road, near US 301.
But the developer has no plans for retail—in other words, the existing small businesses will have to find space elsewhere.
Comments on social media and interviews with owners and employees of the soon-to-be homeless small businesses suggest there’s a growing question: Is it truly “attainable” if we lose the very things that make the neighborhood worth living in? When we trade a dozen local small businesses and a century-old tree canopy for a parking garage and 300 market-rate, plus a few dozen subsidized apartments, what is the net gain for Sarasota?
The DRC meeting this morning didn’t end with a final vote; that’s not what they do. Instead, they gave the developers a list of technical hurdles to clear regarding traffic flow and neighborhood setbacks. But the message was sent: the “Superblock” is coming, and the “Village” is on its way out.
As planners do not seem to have substantial concerns, the project is expected to move toward the Planning Board later this year.
Reporting for WSLR News, I’m Ed James III.
WSLR News aims to keep the local community informed with our 1/2 hour local news show, quarterly newspaper and social media feeds. The local news broadcast airs on Wednesdays and Fridays at 6pm.