Dr. Rachael Shelley’s departure comes amid steep budget cuts. Newtown leaders want a voice in the search of her successor.
By Ed James III
Original Air Date: April 15, 2026
Host: A major figure of the Newtown community is leaving the stage. After fifteen years leading the Tornadoes and thirty-seven years in the Sarasota County School District, Booker High School Principal Dr. Rachel Shelley announced her retirement. Her departure comes at a critical time for the district, which is navigating significant budget cuts. WSLR’s Ed James III takes a look at the legacy she leaves behind and the high stakes involved in finding her successor.
Dr. Rachael Shelley
Ed James III: Dr. Rachel Shelley isn’t just a principal; she’s a product of the very community she serves. A native of Newtown and Sarasota, her tenure at Booker High has been defined by a relentless push for excellence. Under her leadership, the school moved from a C to a B rating and gained national recognition for its Visual and Performing Arts program and Law Academy.
Helen James, President of Suncoast Women of Action and a Booker High alum, says Dr. Shelley has had an impact on student achievement.
Helen James: Dr. Rachel Shelley has been at Booker High for the last 15 years. She has done a great job with Booker High. When Dr. Shelley first came to Booker, the grades wasn’t where they are today. Booker is probably a B school, if I’m not mistaken; before that, it was a C school.
EJ: That success wasn’t accidental. It was built on a foundation of high expectations. Katrina Ward, who served as the district’s Supervisor of School Choice for fourteen years, saw firsthand how Dr. Shelley’s leadership style shaped the culture of the campus.
Katrina Ward: Dr. Shelley was a really strong leader for that school. She was one that really had high expectations for her students, for her staff. The type of expectations she had for everyone involved with the Booker High School community was huge.
EJ: Booker High occupies a unique space in Sarasota. It carries the weight of history—a history of forced integration that saw Black students like Helen James pushed into schools like Sarasota High in the late 60s. Yet, through programs like the Law Academy—a four-year magnet program providing a rigorous, specialized curriculum in law studies and criminal justice—and the performing arts, the school has become a destination of choice for a diverse student body across the county.
Trevor Harvey, president of the Sarasota branch of the NAACP, says the district must recognize that Booker is not a cookie-cutter high school.
Trevor Harvey: Booker High School is a unique institution. Being a diverse community-based school, that school can not be looked upon like other comprehensive high schools because other comprehensive high schools, from a history standpoint, don’t bring that level of institutionalism to this community and especially the Newtown community. Whoever fills the role at Booker High School clearly needs to understand the uniqueness and the jewel that that school possesses.
EJ: That uniqueness is why community leaders are demanding a seat at the table for the selection of the next principal. Harvey says he has already met with Superintendent Terry Connor to make it clear that this process must be transparent and inclusive.
TH: The community needs to be at the table. These are conversations that I’ve already had with the superintendent and the executive director of the high school. The community has to be engaged—and I’m not talking about superficially engaged. They’ve got to be engaged and at the table through this process.
EJ: Superintendent Connor faces a balancing act. The district is grappling with job cuts, now reaching teaching positions. Finding a leader who can maintain Dr. Shelley’s momentum while navigating these financial headwinds will be a defining test for his administration.
For Helen James, the requirement for the next principal is simple: they must care for the students with Dr. Shelley’s cultural competency.
HJ: What we would like is for someone to have interest in the community—someone who has interest in our students.
EJ: While the district begins its search, Trevor Harvey reminds us that replacing someone like Dr. Shelley is about more than just filling a vacancy—it’s about ensuring the survival of the progress she built.
TH: I don’t think whoever comes is going to be able to fill Dr. Shelley’s shoes, because Dr. Shelley herself is uniqueness, and I think that’s what solidifies her legacy. But whoever comes has to be close. They’ve got to be very, very close in order for that school to continue on the forward path that all kids—no matter what they look like, but especially the kids in the minority community—come out college-ready.
EJ: Reporting for WSLR News, I’m Ed James III.
WSLR News aims to keep the local community informed with our 1/2 hour local news show, quarterly newspaper and social media feeds. The local news broadcast airs on Wednesdays and Fridays at 6pm.